Three Guys From Italy

Reviews

• Joely R.

  star star star star star_border 29 September 2026

  The perfect place for a slice in jsq. Great chicken rolls too. The usual jersey Italian pizza joint.

• Shamorra B.

  star star star star star_border 27 September 2026

  In Jersey and was hungry. Only options was McDonald's subways and golden Krust. Pretty much everything I could get in Brooklyn so I decided to try pizza from here. The prices are cheap only $2.00 for a plain slice.The plain didn't have too much cheese more sauce than cheese so I tried to ricotta and mozzarella slice. It was soo good and only $2.75. If I'm ever over here again il probably get the same thing again.

• Alexander H.

  star star star star star 23 September 2026

  This is the quintessential, no frills pizza place. It's survived the test of time and changes to the area, and has been serving up perfect pizza by the slice for more than 20 years. This is where the locals go!

• Aaron H.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 12 September 2026

  Worst pizza ever. If you like eating cheese melted on cardboard then this is the place for you!

• Christina S.

  star star star star star_border 12 September 2026

  I have a lot of fond memories with this pizzeria. Ever since I lived in Jersey City this was my go to spot for a quick bite. Even after highschool I stopped in here probably 4x a week with my best friend.
  
  The pizza is delicious! Perfectly crispy, good amount of cheese and sauce. Slice is $2.00 now, prices have gone up over the years but honestly, what hasn't?
  
  They have tons of seating and even a small window on the side to order from, like a walk up window. Service is quick, fast and friendly. Location is great, they are usually busy but that's a good thing, since your guaranteed to get fresh pizza each and every time.
  
  3 guys has been around for yearssss, so obviously they are doing something right. I love em' and glad they exist!